Residential is up 43%

Dee OlenickChief Marketing Officer

6min read

A powerlifter locking out a heavy deadlift in a dim warehouse gym, chalk dust in the air; on the chalkboard behind him: Residential +43%, pest plans x2
Contents
  1. The problem
  2. What changed
  3. The results
  4. What’s next

Anchor Pest Control set out to grow residential, the side of the business where the recurring revenue lives. A year later, Anchor’s own data shows residential up 43%, and recurring pest plans have almost doubled.

Anchor had already been through five marketing agencies. This is what was wrong with the reports, what changed, and what the scoreboard says now.

Up 43%About 30% to about 40%Almost doubled
Residential growth, stated by Dee Olenick, Anchor’s CMO, on camera.Residential’s share of the business, last year to now. James, Vice President, rough estimate.Recurring pest-plan revenue, the subscription slice of residential. Dee, reading Anchor’s numbers.

I think you guys more operate not lead volume but success of the business, not success of how many leads you’re getting to someone.

Carmen, President, Anchor Pest Control

The problem

Carmen bought a one-man pest control operation 21 years ago. By the time he called Free Agency, five agencies had sent him five versions of the same report.

“Oh, we posted this blog, four billion people looked at it,” but none of them were in our service area and my phone didn’t ring.

Carmen, President, Anchor Pest Control

James got the ranking version: “Oh, look, um, we’re ranking really high in raccoons and garbage cans.” Some months it came as a 30-page document of charts nobody explained. When something failed, nobody said so. The agencies, he says, “never gave us like the ugly truth on stuff if something didn’t work.”

Paid search was worse, because it looked like an answer. Everything Google sold them showed up as one line.

So I didn’t know if AdWords was working great, and then other agencies would put everything together into one, “Oh, Google’s working,” and not break it down.

Carmen, President, Anchor Pest Control

Asked to finish the sentence “Before Free Agency, I thought marketing was,” Carmen picked “confusing,” then went further: “Like, they’ll manipulate you and tell you what they think you wanna hear or put it in a way you don’t understand.”

So why did it last through five agencies? Because the company kept growing, and growth makes a bad report look right.

we always grew, so sometimes I’d be like, “Well, maybe they are right and I’m just missing it.” So I would let it go longer than I probably should’ve

Carmen, President, Anchor Pest Control

What changed

Every channel got its own number. Google was split into its parts and each source was tied to jobs, so ROAS could be read channel by channel. Carmen calls it “actually tying it back to actual job per job, not just as a whole.” The old habit was to let a channel run “six, nine months” on a hunch. James on the new one: “I love the getting granular with that, ’cause that really helped us know, like, ‘Okay, well this isn’t working. Stop it.’”

Somebody listened to the calls. Anchor’s team had been avoiding the price on the phone, worried about sticker shock. Dee heard it in call review and asked why. They moved to a script that gives a starting price, and James says “we’ve had a better success rate with booking.” He has not put a number on it, so neither will we. Carmen’s take on the review itself: “you spend the time to actually do some call by call review, which I don’t think any agency that I’ve dealt with actually does.”

Ads came down when the trucks could not get there. In one area, they did not have the technicians to do the work. When the time to get a technician out slipped past a day or two, the spend came down. “We cut the spend on there so we’re not bleeding money either,” James says. Dee’s logic, in her words: “if a bat’s in my house like and you tell me you’re gonna come up in two days, like that thing’s gonna poop all over my bedroom. Like sorry, next person.”

Anchor did its half. This part is theirs. Carmen put AI coaching on “every piece of the sales process, and the coaching part has gotten better, so our close rate has gone up.” The same job-level numbers now show up in pricing conversations, including whether the initial price covers return on ad spend. And the field had to carry the volume: “So there wasn’t like a, a lull at any point in the summer.”

The hard conversations went both ways. Carmen brought this one up himself. At one point he told Bri he wasn’t happy with something. This is what she said back, as he tells it:

Bri, the owner, is so confident in her service at one point where we were talking about something I wasn’t happy with, and she was like, “I’ll write you a check for everything you... If you’re not happy, I’ll write you a check for everything you paid for the last six months, and you guys can move on. No hard feelings.” And I was just like, “All right.” Someone who really believes in what they’re doing.

Carmen, President, Anchor Pest Control

That is what Bri told Anchor, once, about one problem. It is not a refund policy and it is not a guarantee.

The results

Residential is up 43%. Dee pulled that number straight from Anchor’s data. Residential is where Anchor wants to grow, because it is where the recurring revenue lives.

The mix moved from about 70/30 to about 60/40. James: “I think last year was about, what, 70/30, something like that. Close to it. And now we’re like 60% commercial, 40% residential.” Commercial is the first number. Residential went from about 30% of the business to about 40% in a year.

Recurring pest plans almost doubled. Dee, to Carmen and James: “I was looking at your guys’ numbers, like we’ve almost doubled in that recurring revenue for pest plans.” Plans bill monthly “just like Netflix or any other subscription base,” and James is plain about the goal: “Like, I want them with us until they move or they die, if I’m being honest.”

One caution. None of these numbers separates marketing from everything else Anchor fixed this year. Better call handling, AI sales coaching, pricing conversations, and a busy season all moved at once. We would rather say that than claim the whole 43%.

What’s next

Retention is the next target. Carmen admits it was not tracked closely before. “So one of our core initiatives for the new year is we’re gonna hire someone to oversee retention and really figure out little ways to keep every customer happy.”

His math for next year is small gains stacked on each other: “if you fix the, fix the booking rate by 5%, close rate 5%, it just compounds down, right?”

James does not expect either of them to be satisfied when it works: “the beast is never full, you know? We just keep wanting to grow and continue being successful.”

Written byDee OlenickChief Marketing Officer

A Free Agency CMO: embedded as the marketing leader inside a client's business, building the plan and running every partner, channel and budget line against it. Holds the Free Agency CMO certification.